From Harbin to Seoul: The Scam-Like Casting
Before she became the vocal powerhouse of fourth-generation K-pop, Ning Yizhuo was a child performer navigating China's competitive talent show circuit. Born in Harbin—the capital of Heilongjiang province in China's northeast—she appeared on China's Got Talent Season 2 at just eight years old in 2011, demonstrating the bold stage presence that would define her career. By 2015, at age 12, she competed on Zhejiang Satellite TV's Let's Sing Kids Season 3, where her emotional ballad performances and technical vocal range caught the attention of SM Entertainment scouts watching from Seoul.
The recruitment approach became part of K-pop lore. SM Entertainment contacted Ningning directly through social media after watching her competition videos—a message she immediately dismissed. "After watching the videos where I participated in those auditions, SM sent me a direct message on my old social media account," she recounted on Lee Mujin Service in 2024. "Their message was a shady one... it looked like a typical scam." She didn't reply at first. But unlike her future groupmates—Karina received an Instagram DM she thought was fraudulent, Winter was approached at a dance festival where the scout refused to name the company—Ningning's path began entirely through her Chinese performance footage. Only Giselle took SM's traditional Saturday audition route.
At just 14 years old, Ningning flew to Korea with her mother, spent a week navigating the unfamiliar industry landscape, and signed her contract with SM Entertainment. On September 19, 2016, she was publicly introduced as a member of SM Rookies—the company's pre-debut training team—becoming the first Chinese female trainee revealed since f(x)'s Victoria years earlier. Winter later recalled that when she joined SM in 2017, Ningning had already been disclosed as an SM Rookie: "I felt like I was watching a celebrity."

